Categories
Uncategorized

Book Comparison

No Country For Old Men and The Grapes of Wrath

To start off both books have similar country settings, No Country for Old Men takes place down in a barren part of Texas by the border, while The Grapes of Wrath takes place in the panhandles of Oklahoma as the Joad family moves west across the desolated south western part of the US. On a character aspect, Ed Tom Bell and Pa are quite similar, they both come from an older generation when times were much simpler. During the Joad journey, Pa quickly wears out and hands the role of the leader of the family down to Tom. Ed Tom Bell is worn down as a sheriff thinking about retiring because his job has very much turned into a young man’s game; both characters realize that they are not youthful enough to continue their previous life roles. In each challenge that characters face in both books, they refuse to accept defeat. In No Country for Old Men, Moss fights until his death, and never once believes that he will die at the hands of Chirguh, which leads to the death of Carla Jean, but nonetheless, he never gives up. In The Grapes of Wrath, the Joad family never gives up, despite every setback during their journey, every person that tells them not to go to California, they continue on.

2 replies on “Book Comparison”

Yes I agree that No Country and Grapes of Wrath are very similar which is why they qualify as Great American Novels. By taking place in the southern western areas of the US they show important sides to America’s history. Also like you side with Ed Tom Bell and Pa are similar since they signify the constantly changing culture and they face some confusion the differentiation between the morals of how they grew up versus the younger people in their time period.

Like

I concur that in setting, both of these novels are quite similar and have the same feel to them while reading, as well as some character comparisons which you have made. However, at the end of the day, each have their own respective lesson behind them. No Country for Old Men being how your fate impacts you, and Grapes of Wrath being more politically focusses.

Like

Leave a comment

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started